2018-04-09 Beacon NY - There is little doubt that many of us — me included — increasingly define ourselves, our value, and the meaning of our lives through our work. Yes, I worked part of the day both Saturday and Sunday, again. Of course I tell myself that this is because I'm writing a book. But as soon as this book is done, I have plans for another. And a major new research project. And growing Work Futures into an institute, not just a newsletter and blog. And. And. And.
Perfect preable to the next section, I think.
Sign up here for notifications of free posts. I'll get you to subscribe eventually, I bet.
On The Cult Of Overwork
Visakan Veerasamy posted a deeply dystopian and disturbing tweetstorm that includes hundreds of images, and one of the threads is about our obsessive and desperate relationship with work. Here's some of the images:


Perhaps most troubling, a headline from the Wall Street Journal, about workplace suicides:
I read the article, and it matter-of-factly describes numerous office suicides, employees' reactions, and management responses. The only truly jarring note is the subtitle in the image above: 'sudden and traumatic, the incidents can prompt ripples of anger and guilt across an organization, potentially damaging productivity', the last phrase of which seems callous.
There is a strong undercurrent in the discourse about work and our relationship to it that seems to almost glorify overwork. Jia Tolentino wrote about this in the New Yorker last year, featuring the same image from Fiverr as shown in Veeraswamy's tweet storm. Tolentino told the story of the Lyft driver who accepted riders as she went into labor, and how the company used that as marketing on the Lyft blog:
Mary’s story looks different to different people. Within the ghoulishly cheerful Lyft public-relations machinery, Mary is an exemplar of hard work and dedication—the latter being, perhaps, hard to come by in a company that refuses to classify its drivers as employees. Mary’s entrepreneurial spirit—taking ride requests while she was in labor!—is an “exciting” example of how seamless and flexible app-based employment can be. Look at that hustle! You can make a quick buck with Lyft anytime, even when your cervix is dilating.
[...]
It does require a fairly dystopian strain of doublethink for a company to celebrate how hard and how constantly its employees must work to make a living, given that these companies are themselves setting the terms. And yet this type of faux-inspirational tale has been appearing more lately, both in corporate advertising and in the news. Fiverr, an online freelance marketplace that promotes itself as being for “the lean entrepreneur”—as its name suggests, services advertised on Fiverr can be purchased for as low as five dollars—recently attracted ire for an ad campaign called “In Doers We Trust.” One ad, prominently displayed on some New York City subway cars, features a woman staring at the camera with a look of blank determination. “You eat a coffee for lunch,” the ad proclaims. “You follow through on your follow through. Sleep deprivation is your drug of choice. You might be a doer.”
[...]
At the root of this is the American obsession with self-reliance, which makes it more acceptable to applaud an individual for working himself to death than to argue that an individual working himself to death is evidence of a flawed economic system.
Joseph Pieper was a German philosopher of the last century who said that we've moved into a time of 'total work'. I discovered Pieper through Maria Popova, who quoted him:
The original meaning of the concept of “leisure” has practically been forgotten in today’s leisure-less culture of “total work”: in order to win our way to a real understanding of leisure, we must confront the contradiction that rises from our overemphasis on that world of work.
[…]
The very fact of this difference, of our inability to recover the original meaning of “leisure,” will strike us all the more when we realize how extensively the opposing idea of “work” has invaded and taken over the whole realm of human action and of human existence as a whole.
Pieper pointed out that the original Greek term for leisue is associated with our term school and scholar, and we've come to consider it narrowly as 'time not working' instead of its original sense of increasing our knowledge and artistry.
And Pieper poses an existential question, which I fear we have sidestepped, these days, as we've accepted the tyrrany of work:
What is normal is work, and the normal day is the working day. But the question is this: can the world of man be exhausted in being “the working world”? Can the human being be satisfied with being a functionary, a “worker”? Can human existence be fulfilled in being exclusively a work-a-day existence?
Pushed too far in that direction, we arrive at Veerasamy's tweetstorm.
…
Amanda Hess wrote last summer about Aggretsuko (aggressive Suko), a cartoon that is all about work rage:
My new favorite cartoon character is a white-collar red panda with anger issues.
Her name is Aggretsuko, and she’s a young Japanese “office associate” who leaps, tail wagging, into her first job, only to suffer countless slights at the hands of her co-workers. In each online micro-episode — all are one minute long, perfect for Instagram snacking — her colleagues in the accounting department of a Tokyo trading company drop work on her desk at closing time, slurp noodles over her shoulder and inappropriately brag about their dating exploits.
As the indignities mount, Aggretsuko (pronounced ah-GRET-su-KO) smiles courteously and types studiously. But inside her head, she slips into rage mode, where she chugs beers and performs death metal karaoke as flames spark around her face. Her inner monologue spills out in a guttural scream: “DON’T BELITTLE MEEEEEEEEEEEE!” and “BUZZ OOOOOOOOOOFF!” After following her travails for a few weeks, I downloaded Aggretsuko wallpaper to my phone so that I see her whenever I check my email. She is perched on a rolling chair, paws hovering over the keyboard, a coquettish smile on her face. The caption reads: “I HATE THIS.”
[...]
Aggretsuko’s experience surely resonates with many young women who have come up against the sexist, or just plain dehumanizing, demands of corporate culture as they embark on careers.
The original one minute format has been expanded into 15 minute segments on Netflix.
…
More office rage.
On Diversity
Slack has been doing a better job of employing minority employees than other tech companies, according to its recent reports, according to Jessica Nordell:
Slack has been outperforming other Silicon Valley companies, and its current numbers show that the trend has continued. At Google, Facebook, and Microsoft, women hold between 19 percent and 28 percent of leadership positions and between 19 percent and 20 percent of technical roles, according to those companies’ most recent figures. At Slack, women make up 31 percent of leaders and hold 34 percent of technical roles. Also, in Slack’s U.S. workforce, percentages of underrepresented minorities (including black or African-American, Hispanic or Latino, or American Indian or Alaskan employees), are, in some cases, triple that of peer companies. At Google, Facebook, and Microsoft, underrepresented minorities hold between 4 and almost 8 percent of technical roles and make up less than 11 percent of all employees. At Slack, by contrast, underrepresented minorities make up almost 13 percent of technical roles and roughly 13 percent of all employees; they also make up 6 percent of leadership. The number of Hispanic women at the company has more than doubled since last year. The number of Hispanic men more than quadrupled.
How is this happening? A amazingly effective Head of Diversity? No. Just the opposite:
At Slack, the absence of a single diversity leader seems to signal that diversity and inclusion aren’t standalone missions, to be shunted off to a designated specialist, but are rather intertwined with the company's overall strategy. As the CEO, Stewart Butterfield, has said, he wants these efforts to be something “everyone is engaged in.” Indeed, as the research by [Harvard professor Frank] Dobbin and colleagues shows, involving employees in diversity policies leads to greater results.
And looking in different places, too:
For one thing, the company has, since 2015, proactively sought out candidates from outside traditional programmer pipelines like Stanford and MIT, recruiting through all-women’s coding camps like Hackbright, as well as programs that focus on training black and Latino programmers such as Code2040. Recruiters are trained to look at skills rather than a candidate’s university pedigree.
And the company has worked to block bias, like 'whiteboard interviews' in favor of 'blind code reviews' — following the format of blind auditions orchestras now often use — which remove all indicators of race, gender, and so on.
And Slack reworked the interview process to get at the specific information needed to judge candidates for their roles, and then they asked all candidates exactly the same questions.
Nordell closes with these thoughts:
When a company puts intense effort into diversity and inclusion, it serves as a signal to employees that the company takes it seriously, and that, in itself, can have a positive effect on things like employee morale or feelings of inclusion. If trying to improve diversity and inclusion is the norm, even if the results aren't perfect, it confirms a commitment and concern about these issues.
Comments
Post a Comment