Monday Note #483 - Publishers should go for “Smart Curation” market (FF) — Watch my hands: Corporate Taxes Magic (JLG)
From: Monday Note
Received: January 31, 2018 at 07:56PM
from Gmail
via IFTTT
Monday Note #483 January 28, 2018 Why publishers should consider the “Smart Curation” market by Frederic Filloux An early version of the Smart Curation system (Nasa) News publishers have the opportunity to enter the curation business by leveraging their reputations as trusted sources, and on proven technologies. Curation has been consistently ignored by big media companies. By curation, I mean lifting what is relevant from a journalistic perspective and selectively linking to it. This is the implementation of Jeff Jarvis’ 2007 encyclical: “Cover what you do best and link to the rest”. This principle collided with the conservatism of the news industry. Linking to other sites, large or small, was viewed as a ludicrous idea — “Sending my traffic outside, are you nuts?! ” — by the very same crowd who later spent countless resources to show up high on Facebook and Google. Now in a funny turnaround, they realize that Facebook brings them next to nothing and that, at least according to Rupert Murdoch, platforms should pay for premium content (Dream on, Rupert…) Now let’s look at the future. There are many reasons for publishers to reconsider developing a curation service. 1. Their journalistic firepower is dwindling. In the US alone, the traditional journalism workforce has been halved from its peak in the 1990s. The ability to cover the news broadly and in depth is at its lowest point (paving the way for historical misses, such as the strength of the Trump electorate). 2. Symmetrically, the pool of sources has never been greater. Expertise is now widely available in every field — but it can be hard to find and to evaluate. 3. Publishers, old and new, tend to underestimate the power of their authority. A link suggested by a trusted source is invaluable for readers; far from abandoning their referral, they tend to come back to their valued news source. Assuming that publishers overcome their reluctance to systematically link to an external source, their biggest hurdle will be to manage and sort the flow of content. Full disclosure here. I have skin in that game. One of the applications of The News Quality Scoring platform I’m currently working at the John S. Knight Fellowship at Stanford is to foster curation processes, using a feature I call “Smart Curation.” The following scenario involves a fictitious news outlet harboring a competent staff of several hundred — a third down from ten years ago, but still able to cover a large spectrum of the news cycle. Each news desk, each beat reporter, has provided a list of the digital sources they monitor on a regular basis. The technology desk maintains a large list of niche publications, sometimes run by a handful of writers. So do the science editors. The macro-economics specialists have suggested a catalog of websites ranging from monetary policy watchers to business blogs in Asia. Altogether, they have collected about 500 websites. Some of them publish dozens of news stories per day while others produce a few articles a month. The total output on any given day reaches several thousand articles, of which only a fraction are viewed by humans — a large number are spotted too late or simply ignored. More importantly, none of this material is passed along to readers. Understandably frustrated, sophisticated news consumers maintain their own news-gathering systems, using news aggregators like Feedly (the deepest and most customizable of all), Nuzzel (a clever social recommendation engine), or Laserlike, a startup manned by Google search alums. Laserlike relies on “interests” the user has to enter manually. (For example, my stream is based on 66 items ranging from companies like “Toutiao,” “Red Digital Cinema,” “Deep Mind,” “Calico” or “AWS,” to names like “Norman Foster,” “Reed Hastings,” “Andrew Ng” and various geeky stuff about algorithms, digital imaging technologies and neuroscience.) All of these services are quite efficient indeed, but require a certain motivation. But since none of the mainstream news outlets I look at regularly — including about nine I pay for — is able to give me the holistic view I need, I had to build my own makeshift newsfeeds. We are millions of readers doing exactly the same thing. Coming back to my scenario. The hypothetical publisher operates a Smart Curation platform that monitors 500 websites recommended by the newsrooms. The filtering system is based on multiple signals able to detect journalistic value-added, like the depth and thoroughness of an article, information density, (measuring the ratio of quotes), named entities, readability, etc. Over time, the system has been tweaked to reflect the reputation of some authors or the weight of specific sub-subjects that deserve particular attention. The most recent version relies on current machine learning techniques, such as computing vectors’ representations of words (like Word2vec or, GloVe — the kinds of things we used in the development of the News Quality Scoring Project). The Smart Curation Platform surfaces only a few percent of what it “sees”; it will surface headlines and one or two lines of text. (Pushing a bit further, the link can be displayed along with a few lines of summary, generated by the platform — the technology exists.) A manual verification of the skimmed links will be done by the newsroom, especially in the training phase of the model. After awhile, the system can operate autonomously and reliably. The primary beneficiaries will be the readers. Without leaving the environment of their favorite news sources, they will have a much deeper view of the news cycle. The news brand will reinforce its status as trusted “prescriber” of valuable information — critical, at the current time. Smart Curation could easily be a service integrated into a paid-for, premium package, valued for its relevance and its brevity. In the next Monday Note, we’ll look at how the Smart Curation platform could open the way to a vastly improved personalization system, thanks to another feature of the NQS Project, the Quality Tag (Qtag). — frederic.filloux@mondaynote.com ▶︎ For regular updates about the News Quality Scoring Project and to participate in various tests we are going to make, subscribe now: Corporate Taxes Magic by Jean-Louis Gassée Companies that manage to pay lower taxes — or no taxes at all — by exporting profits to friendlier locales claim that such moves are legal. While, indeed, no CEO has ever been jailed for it, many see the dodge as a hateful, immoral state of affairs. There should be a way… It’s Quarterly Earnings Season again, which means we’ll soon suffer the ritual headline contests. First we get hyperventilating guesswork in anticipation of sales, profit, and guidance numbers, followed by (equally hyperventilating) analyses of financial legerdemain when results are announced: See! Profits magically disappear from their native country and resurface in a comfier location. How does it work? Watch my hands. Company X in Country A develops Patent P. Shortly thereafter, Company X moves the patent to an affiliate in Country B, a nice place with much lower tax rates. At year’s end, Company X “discovers” it must pay royalties for the use of Patent P. As a result, taxable income moves from Country A to Country B. If the tax rate in Country A is 50% but it’s only 5% in Country B, this results in $45 saved for every $100 of revenue. Nice. And completely legal, if not entirely palatable. With an important side effect: Cash piles accumulate in Country B. It’s a scheme that many companies — tech, fashion, industrial, natural resources, or otherwise — use today to move profits to friendlier climes. But the prestidigitation isn’t new. In 1981, France elected François Mitterrand, a Socialist president who proceeded to “curb the power of money” by nationalizing banks and industrial companies. While many protested this confiscation of assets, one of France’s richest men, aircraft maker Marcel Dassault, remained serene and pledged his patriotic support to the new régime. The reason for Dassault’s equanimity quickly came to the surface: Dassault Aviation, of Mirage and Falcon fame, had assigned its patents to the Swiss holding company it owned, an arrangement that lowered the company’s corporate taxes in France by moving a large part of its profits, in the form of royalty payments, to a lower tax locale. And, again, it was entirely legal. There we have it: The corporate cross-border tax monte. More complicated arrangements arise — schemes with colorful names like Double Irish and Dutch Sandwich — but the root idea, the necessary condition is the unimpeded movement of intellectual property across borders, a free and legal alchemy that turns profits into royalty payments. You may protest that the game is unethical, it demonstrates poor citizenship, it deprives communities of tax revenues that could be used for schools, infrastructure, lower taxes for the middle class, etc. Corporate chieftains reply that they scrupulously follow the law, that they have a fiduciary obligation to their owners and shareholders. Objections to the scheme generate effective headlines, but actual protests are usually disingenuous and willfully uninformed. For example, a French fiscal justice organization called ATTAC blocked access to a Paris Apple store, demanding that the company pay its taxes. Headlines sided with the protestors and chastised the company’s accounting shenanigans. But when I asked a local journalist if other French companies used similar tax optimization tactics I was told (honestly, at least) that other companies aren’t as newsworthy as Apple. So how do we solve the problem of profits moving across borders unimpeded? The reporter gave me a very Gallic shrug: Maybe an international agreement providing the same tax rate everywhere? Changes to US corporate tax law and the recent repatriation arrangements mitigate the problem, but they’re not an ultimate solution. When companies dangle the prospect of a huge new factory, or a corporate HQ, or even sport stadiums in exchange for tax concessions, US communities fall over each to be first in line, offering larger and larger incentives. Why would countries behave differently? To solve the problem, we would need to regulate the movement of intellectual properties across borders. Today, if you sell a patent, you pay taxes on the profit from the sale. Value changes hands, the tax man gets a piece of the action. (The calculation is complicated by timing considerations and costs allocated to the development of the patent, but accountants know how to handle it.) But if you “sell to yourself” — if you transfer the intellectual property to your own subsidiary in another country, a la Dassault — there is no taxable event and the valuable patent can now be used to tunnel profits from Country A into Country B. This tax-free transfer generates a huge amount of future profits based on the revenue stream the patent will generate. A look at the hundreds of billions exfiltrated by companies such as Apple and Google (and thousands of others across the world) shows the magnitude of the problem. We could attempt to tax the intra-company transfer of a patent, but on what basis? How does the tax person assess the present value of future royalty payments? Short of prohibiting such transfers, there seems to be no realistic possibility to avoid the legal exfiltration of profits. That such transfers kept happening right under the noses of so many vigilant tax entities for so many decades should give us a hint of the basic impossibility. Now let’s consider US tax law as applied to individuals: Whatever you make, anywhere in the world, you pay taxes to the IRS. (And also to the country where you made the money? Not if the country has a tax treaty with the mighty US.) Why not tax corporations on their worldwide income no matter where it’s produced, just as we do individuals? After all, a Supreme Court decision nicknamed Citizens United is often characterized as holding that corporations ought to enjoy the same rights as citizens; should they not abide by the same tax rules? I’m not serious. With apologies to the august body, this is a gross misrepresentation of the Supreme Court decision. Taxing corporations in the same manner as individuals would be wildly impractical with countries fighting tooth and nail with Uncle Sam for their piece of the action. So the IP-lubricated profit transfers will continue, somewhat mitigated by lower corporate tax rates…until they change again. — JLG@mondaynote.com Unsubscribe instantly from these emails by clicking here.
Received: January 31, 2018 at 07:56PM
from Gmail
via IFTTT
Comments
Post a Comment